SELECTION OF QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
APRIL2010 PART 3
I have a seemingly intellectual question which to me is actually a practical practice-question.
I have many times seen what I think happen, many times in magical ways. Since mind is the highest level, is it more important what we think than even choosing our particular practice regimen correctly?
— Alex, USA
Editorial Note: Alex's other questions are posted in the April 2010 Part 2 issue.
Depending on different variables, the answer can be yes or no, yes and no, or neither yes nor no.
At you level, where you have developed a powerful mind and you practice high-level chi kung, the answer is yes, what you think is more important than choosing the best exercise.
For many people whose mind is not yet developed and they practice low-level chi kung, the answer is no, choosing the right exercise is more important than what they think.
For masters, the answer is yes and no. Yes, because their mind is so powerful, it does not matter what exercise they choose. No, because they are so skillful when practicing a well chosen exercise, it does not matter what they think. Yes and no, because their mind is powerful and they are very skillful, whatever exercise they choose will give them good results, and they may vary their emphasis on mind or skill whenever they like.
For those who practice gentle physical exercise, or practice chi kung incorrectly, the answer is neither yes nor no. It doesn't matter whether they have a positive mind-set or have chosen a right chi kung exercise, they still would not have any chi kung result. Why is it that they have no chi kung benefit when they practice a right chi kung exercise? It is because they practice it as gentle physical exercise or they practice it wrongly. Using the car analogy, they have a car but they do not drive it or they drive it wrongly.
For example if people have health problems and they practice chi-kung diligently but hold strongly to the fact that they have diabetes, bad back or any particular illness, will this prevent chi from clearing out those health problems?
Again, the answer is yes or no, yes and no, or neither yes nor no, depending on different variables.
If the health problems are not serious, the chi kung they practice is powerful, and they practice correctly, their negative mind-set does not prevent chi from clearing their problems. In other words, they will recover. Of course, their result will be much faster and better if they have a positive mind-set.
Reversely, if their health problems are serious, their chi kung is low-level, and they practice unsatisfactorily, their negative mind-set will prevent chi flow from clearing their health problems.
When the variables are a mixture of positive and negative, the answer is sometimes yes and sometimes no. When positive factors predominate, the negative mind-set may not prevent the chi flow. When negative factors predominate, the negative mind-set aggravates the prevention of chi flow.
If they practice chi kung wrongly, though diligently, or they practice chi kung patterns as gentle physical exercise, as most people do, technically speaking the answer is neither yes nor no as there is no chi flow for their negative mind-set to prevent.
On a personal practice level is it more important to set good aims and objectives and then enjoy my practice, than to make sure I choose an optimal practice regimen?
Yes, having set good aims and objectives, enjoying your practice is certainly more important than ensuring you have chosen an optimal practice regimen. I would like to emphasize that this answer applies to our Shaolin Wahnam members. It may not be applicable to other people.
The answer fits in perfectly well with our three golden rules of practice, namely not to worry, not to intellectualize and enjoy the practice. Constantly attempting to ensure choosing an optimal practice regiment falls under worrying and intellectualizing.
Will the chi flow naturally follow the mind's direction as specified in my aims and objectives?
As in many things in our arts, the answer can be yes, no, either yes or no, neither yes nor no Using my earlier answers as guidelines, you can work out the answer for this question yourself for your intellectual pleasure. But when you are practicing, you don't worry about the question nor intellectualize on the answer.
My tutor who is a 2nd Dan says that each part of Tai Chi though slowed down can be a strike in a fighting style if it is performed fast.
— Glennis, UK
Your tutor is right.
When one starts to learn Tai Chi Chuan, he performs the movements slowly for two main objectives. It enables him to perform the movements smoothly and correctly. It also enables him to generate an energy flow. Most Tai Chi students today, however, fail to achieve the second objective.
When a student can perform the Tai Chi Chuan movements smoothly and correct as well as is able to generate an energy flow, he progresses to performing the movements fast and powerfully yet in a relaxed and gentle manner.
This may sound odd to many people. They wonder how a person could be relaxed and gentle yet fast and powerful at the same time. Of course, this is possible. This, in fact, is the hall-mark of Tai Chi Chuan.
A remarkable difference between Tai Chi Chuan and other genuine internal martial arts on one hand and external martial arts on the other hand, is that the internal practitioners can be relaxed, gentle, powerful and fast at the same time, whereas external martial art practitioners need to tense their muscles to be powerful, and when they attempt to be fast they lose some of their power.
As Tai Chi Chuan is a martial art, many Tai Chi Chuan movements are effective strikes. Most practitioners today, however, practice Tai Chi Chuan as a slow, external exercise, without any understanding or experience of its fast, powerful martial aspects.
Where can I find a book that has this info in it, so that if I make a fist it might knock a person over like a fighting style?
You can find a lot of such information in my book, "The Complete Book of Tai Chi Chuan".
A skillful Tai Chi Chuan practitioner can knock down a person with any part of his body.besides his fist, such as his fingers, palm, forearm, elbow, shoulder, thigh, shin and foot. Indeed, because he uses internal force, his strikes with his palms or fingers are more powerful than with his fists.
But there are many more worthy results of practicing Tai Chi Chuan besides knocking down a person with just one strike.
I am told that "ch'uan" is the fighting style and "tai chi" isn't. I am confused as I am also told they are the same.
The word "chuan" means martial art. The term "tai chi" literally means "grand ultimate", but figuratively means the Cosmos. Hence Tai Chi Chuan means Cosmos Martial Art or Cosmos Kungfu.
However, many people who practice Tai Chi Chuan nowadays practice it as an external gentle exercise like a dance instead of a martial art. They also shortened the term "Tai Chi Chuan" to "Tai Chi".
Can you help me? As I am disabled with arthritis I constantly have to fight pain and fatigue and have no pain killers. It was by learning Tai Chi back in 1995 that I was able to walk when I was told I would never walk again.
Congratulations for being able to walk again after practicing Tai Chi Chuan. This was a great achievement.
You also have a chance to overcome your arthritis and be pain free. I would recommend that you attend my Intensive Chi Kung Course or Intensive Tai Chi Chuan Course . However, I offer the Intensive Tai Chi Chuan Course only when many people request for it.
- Developing Internal Force Using Siu Lin Tou
- Facts and Opinions
- What you Learn at the Intensive Shaolin Kungfu Course
- Evolution: the Monkey Viewpoint
- It's a Common Mistake to Practie the Iron-Wire Set as an Isometric Exercise